How do we pick the right school?
Find real fit, not perceived fit. Let your list change as you visit and talk to coaches. Think career path first, then major. And remember that wherever you end up, it is your responsibility to make the most of it.
“Regardless of where you end up, it is still your responsibility to make the most of your experience.”
Coach Scott MacLean
Fit, not perception
The thing families get wrong most often is perception versus fit. What others say from the couch is different from what fits you. Many of Coach Scott's players did not realize they preferred a smaller school until they started talking about it.
Your list can and will and should evolve, and that takes live reps: visits, calls, and time on campuses. After months of homework, the decision usually comes down to feel. What feels like home.
Career first, then the major
Steer toward a career path first, then the major. Colleges have many ways to shape a major toward a career, so talk with advisors at every school on your list.
Three questions to ask every college coach
- Where am I in your recruiting process, and what role and roster spot are you evaluating me for? It tells you the timeline and where you really fit.
- What would my development and my academic experience look like if I'm not playing much? Ask about academic support and a freshman's day, and ask to talk with current players if they don't offer.
- What exactly will our family pay, what is committed in writing, and what could change? The financial aid office answers some of this, but talk about it with the coach too.
One question to skip: "Will I play as a freshman?" A coach has to see you in practice and decide what is best for the team at the time. A promise made long before you step on the field isn't worth much.
What if we pick wrong?
That question is drenched in things you can't control. A school could be perfect with the best coach and something could still go wrong. You could go somewhere far from perfect and, with the things you control, make it the best experience ever. Shift to that mindset and you won't pick wrong.
- Visit two campuses this season, even unofficially.
- Write down what you liked and what you didn't before you leave each one.
- Ask an advisor at each school how a major leads to the career you want.
- Rank your list again after every visit.